Best anal toys, ranked by Coyscore

Seven anal toys ranked by aggregated review data — serums that relax without numbing, plugs that stay put, and strokers built to last. We scored them on beginner-friendliness, material safety, ease of use and what reviewers actually said about living with them. The top pick has 165 reviews and sits at 4.8 stars.

We ranked these seven products by Coyscore, which aggregates star ratings and review text across retailers and weights them for beginner-friendliness, body safety, ease, performance, satisfaction and value. All seven have a Coyscore; between them they carry 1,133 reviews. The score tells you what held up in ordinary use, not what looked good in the packet.

Intimate Earth Daring Anal Relaxing Serum for Men 30 ml — the top-scoring product here, and the one reviewers return to. It relaxes without numbing, so you keep the feedback that tells you when to slow down. Absorbs quickly, no greasy residue, and the 30 ml bottle lasts. 165 reviews, 4.8 stars, Coyscore 89.

Pipedream Extreme Toyz Bubble Butt Fanta Flesh Ass and Vagina — realistic enough that reviewers struggle to describe it without hyperbole, heavy enough to stay exactly where you put it, and soft where it matters. The dual-entry design gives you options. Cleaning takes commitment — bring it into the shower and give it time to dry. 90 reviews, 4.3 stars, Coyscore 83.

Relax Anal Relaxer — does what the name says, at a price that makes it easy to try. Reviewers appreciate that it works without drama and washes off cleanly. Not the most elegant product here, but it is effective and the 128-review average suggests people keep using it. 3.9 stars, Coyscore 73.

We capped the list at one product per brand, which removed four others. Where a manufacturer appears more than once in the ranked data, we took the highest-scoring product and moved on — the goal is variety, not a catalogue of one company's range.

Does this serum numb the area? No, the serum is designed to relax without numbing, allowing for pleasure without masking important sensations. As one user noted, it "relaxes without numbing, making it easier without taking away the pleasure" (Pinkcherry).

Is this product easy to use? Yes, users found it "easy to apply, absorbs well" (Pinkcherry) and that it "makes warm up easier" (An0nymousAnal, Reddit).

How realistic does this toy feel? Reviewers consistently praise its realism, describing it as "Ultra realistic feeling" (Pinkcherry, 06/29/26) and "Like real. I don't lie." (Pinkcherry, 07/03/26).

Is it easy to clean? It's generally considered "Not too bad to clean though as long as you're willing to bring it in the shower with you" (Mr-Grim-, Reddit r/SexToys), though some find it "kind of hard to dry" (Mr-Grim-, Reddit r/SexToys).

What is the material like? The material is described as "soft but Heavy (GOOD Heavy)" (Pinkcherry, 06/29/26) and "the softest most realistic feeling" (Pinkcherry, 04/02/26).

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.