Doc Johnson — every product, scored

Doc Johnson's anal range sits squarely in the middle of what we score — 15 products averaging 70 points, with three that earn our Recommended grade and a handful you should probably skip. They make training sets, classic plugs and a few genuinely huge toys, mostly in PVC with a small silicone line that scores noticeably better.

The range splits into training kits, everyday plugs, tunnel plugs and toys designed for serious size. The Mood Naughty 1 Trainer Set and the Classic Butt Plug both score 85 and sit at opposite ends of the beginner spectrum — one walks you through three sizes, the other gives you a single well-shaped plug that just works. The Kink F Plug stretches to 10 inches and scores 84, which is rare for something that long.

The middle tier — the Platinum Stretch and the various Ripple plugs — hovers around 76 points. Reviewers like them well enough but flag texture issues and cleaning difficulties, which makes sense given most of this range is PVC. At the bottom you'll find the American Bombshell line, where scores drop into the 50s and review text turns consistently negative. The Hard Rammer and the Rockeye 101 both sit at 49 points across hundreds of reviews, which tells you most of what you need to know.

Three of the 13 products we can confirm are non-porous silicone — the rest are PVC, which means they cannot be sterilised and need a fresh condom each time or strict single-user rules. Two products lack a stated material in the supplier spec, so we cannot score their safety and have marked them unknown.

That 3-in-13 split matters because the silicone products consistently outscore the PVC ones. If you are choosing between a Doc Johnson plug and something from a brand that builds everything in silicone, the silicone brand will usually win on both safety and longevity.

The Mood Naughty 1 Trainer Set scores 85 and gives you three plugs in graduated sizes, all silicone, all with the flared base and tapered shape that make training sets actually useful. Reviewers say the progression feels logical and the smallest one is genuinely small enough to start with, which is rarer than it should be.

The Classic Butt Plug also scores 85 and earns it by doing one thing well — it is a single plug, PVC, with a shape that works for most people and a price that does not ask much of you. If you want to try a plug and do not want to think about it, this is the one. The Kink F Plug scores 84 and stretches to 10 inches, which is a lot of toy for a score that high — reviewers who want serious length say it delivers without the durability complaints that usually come with inflatables.

The Platinum Stretch sits at 79 and the Tripple Ripple Large at 76. Both have review counts in the hundreds, both are PVC, and both attract consistent mentions of texture and cleaning issues. They work, but the silicone options above them work better and last longer.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.