The Anal Twist Dildo 10 Inch vs Andrew Anal Stimulating Vibrator

One is a 10-inch PVC spiral that screws its way in; the other is a 5-inch silicone vibrator shaped for the prostate. Both are designed for anal play, but they ask completely different things of you. The Twist is long, firm and theatrical — the kind of toy that makes an evening of it. The Andrew is compact, body-safe and vibrates, which makes it the more practical choice if you want something that works quickly and cleans properly.

The Anal Twist has 225 reviews averaging 5 stars. The Andrew has 409 reviews averaging 4.1 stars. Both have enough feedback to trust the pattern, and the pattern is clear: the Twist delights the people it suits, while the Andrew works well for most but not quite everyone.

The Twist is 10 inches insertable and made from PVC, which means it cannot be sterilised — keep it to one person and use a fresh condom each time. The Andrew is 5.1 inches, made from silicone, and fully sterilisable with soap and hot water. Both weigh almost exactly the same — around 300 grams — but the Twist is twice the length, so it feels much lighter in the hand and much more present once it's in.

The material difference matters most. Silicone lasts, PVC does not. If you are choosing between them, that is the thing to decide on first.

Neither product states its maximum diameter, whether it has a flared base, or how gradually it tapers. That makes it harder to compare them on the dimensions that matter most for comfort and safety. What we do know is that both are designed for prostate stimulation, both are substantial enough to feel clearly, and both are heavier than most plugs — which some people love and others find tiring.

If you want something you can clean properly and keep for years, the Andrew is the one. If you want length, theatre and the specific sensation of a toy that spirals in as you twist it, the Anal Twist is the one — but accept that it will not last as long and that you will need to be careful with it.

Beginners should start with the Andrew. The Twist is not hostile, but 10 inches is a lot to ask of anyone, and PVC at that length is a commitment you should make only once you know you want it.

What is the point of a spiral twist butt plug? The point is it's fun. You can get the head in then twist it and it will screw its way in deeper, which is a fun feeling.

Is the Anal Twist suitable for extended wear? One user noted it might be easier for it to unscrew itself out compared to a traditional plug for extended wear.

What type of lube should I use with the Andrew? Water-based lube is best to use with silicone toys. Avoid silicone lube as it can react with the toy and ruin it.

Is the Andrew suitable for beginners? While some toys are described as beginner-friendly, it's noted that discovering what works best is a process. For new anal players, a smaller option like the Aneros Helix Syn V is suggested by users on Reddit.

Can the Andrew be used for external anal play? Yes, some users suggest using vibrating toys on the area without full insertion for stimulation, especially if not ready for full penetration.

The Andrew is the better buy for most people. It is body-safe, it vibrates, it is shaped for the prostate, and it will last. The Twist is the better buy if you specifically want length and the spiral sensation, and if you are comfortable with the care that PVC requires. Both have strong review support, but the Andrew's material and practicality make it the safer recommendation unless you already know the Twist is what you want.

Both are stocked at Coy and other retailers. Check current prices and availability before you decide — the Andrew tends to sit around the mid-range, while the Twist is often cheaper, which makes sense given the material.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.