Firefly Pleasure Plug Small Yellow review

A small, smooth plug that glows in the dark — and one that reviewers consistently call easy and comfortable, which matters more than the novelty. It's TPE rather than silicone, so it needs a condom each time, but for a first plug or a bit of low-stakes fun it does exactly what it promises.

Reviewers talk about how straightforward this one is. The taper is gentle, the size is genuinely small, and the texture is smooth enough that insertion doesn't ask much of you. One person called it "easy to use and pain-free", which is about as clear a signal as you get that a plug works for beginners.

The glow is the other thing people mention. Charge it under a lamp for a few moments and it's bright enough to see across a dark room. Some buyers love that — it adds a bit of theatre, and if you're playing in low light it means you always know where the thing is. Others don't care, but nobody says it's gimmicky or poorly done.

The base is wide and sturdy, which means it stays put and doesn't migrate. A few reviewers mention using it during PIV, which tells you it's comfortable enough to forget about once it's in. The weight is light — 65 grams — so you won't feel it the way you would with glass or steel, but that also means it's unobtrusive if you're wearing it for a while.

Cleaning is simple. Soap and warm water, then let it dry. TPE can't be boiled or bleached, so if you're sharing it or moving between uses, put a condom on it. That's not a flaw, it's just what the material asks for.

The one consistent criticism is the material itself. TPE is porous, which means it can't be sterilised the way silicone can. Some sources flag that Firefly's TPE range isn't body-safe in the way their silicone products are, so if material is a deciding factor for you, this isn't the one.

This suits people who are new to anal play and want something that won't intimidate them. The size is small, the taper is forgiving, and reviewers who'd never used a plug before had no trouble with it. If you're training up to something larger, this is a sensible place to start.

It also works for anyone who wants a plug they can wear during sex without it getting in the way. The base is low-profile and the weight is light, so it doesn't demand attention once it's in.

Who should look elsewhere: anyone who needs a non-porous material. TPE can't be sterilised, so if you're sharing it between partners or you want something that will last years without degrading, pick a silicone plug instead. And if you're past the beginner stage and want something with more presence, this one will feel slight.

This sits in the beginner end of the butt plug category — small, smooth, and designed to be easy rather than challenging. It's not trying to be the plug you graduate to; it's the one you start with or keep around for low-key use.

If you want to see where it ranks against other plugs, we've scored and sorted them all on the best butt plugs page.

So is it worth buying, and where do you get it?

Is the Firefly Pleasure Plug body-safe? It's made of TPE, which is porous and can't be sterilised. Some sources note that while other Firefly products are body-safe silicone, the TPE plugs need more care — use a condom each time and keep it to one person.

Does the plug glow in the dark? Yes. Charge it under a lamp for a few moments and it glows brightly enough to see across a dark room. Reviewers say it's a fun addition, not just a gimmick.

Is this plug good for beginners? Yes. Reviewers consistently recommend it for first-time users, calling it easy, comfortable, and pain-free. The size and taper are both forgiving.

A beginner-friendly plug that does what it promises: smooth, comfortable, and genuinely easy to use. The glow-in-the-dark feature is a nice touch, and reviewers who'd never tried anal play before had no trouble with it. The material is the trade-off — TPE can't be sterilised, so use a condom and keep it to yourself. If you want something that will last years, pick silicone. If you want something that works well right now and doesn't cost much, this is a solid choice.

Available for $18.95. The geo-router will show you where to get it depending on where you are.

This review draws on 49 aggregated reviews across 4 retailers, averaging 4.9 stars. The Coyscore is 82, which puts it in the "Coy Recommended" grade. That's a high-confidence score — enough reviews to trust the pattern, and the pattern is consistently positive.

Weight: 0.065 kg (65 grams)
Insertable length: Not stated — "Small" is a size descriptor, not a measurement
Maximum diameter: Not stated
Material: Not stated in supplier spec
Non-porous: Not stated — no material information available to confirm
Flared base: Not stated in supplier spec
Taper: Not stated

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.